Malia Bouattia’s election as NUS president proves deeply divisive


It’s miles rare that the election of a pupil union president merits the flurry of headlines that greeted Malia Bouattia. But her election, because the first black Muslim woman to preserve the workplace, has been one of the most divisive moments in the country wide Union of college students’ current records.

Bouattia’s supporters hail it as a powerful victory for diversity and radical politics; her critics lament her election as a stressful choice that could result in an irreconcilable schism among the union and mainstream pupil opinion.

Jewish students’ organizations say they’re especially alarmed. Bouattia, 28, has been filmed decrying the effect of the “Zionist-led media”, defined her college “Zionist outpost” in a paragraph citing the university’s big Jewish society, and spoke at a meeting advertised using a poster featuring Hassan Nasrallah, the leader of Hezbollah.

However, at this week’s NUS conference, Bouattia changed into overwhelmingly popular choice, triumphing on the primary round through extra than 50 delegate votes and unseating the incumbent, Megan Dunn, a really uncommon incidence.

What hope the combat in opposition to antisemitism whilst Malia Bouattia leads the NUS?


Hannah Weisfeld
study extra
Her two years as NUS black college students’ officer have undoubtedly been massive: she testified at the UN approximately the chilling consequences of anti-extremism programmes on academic freedom; Bouattia driven for greater diverse scholar representation, which includes extra minority ethnic applicants and for an everlasting officer for transgender students; on level at NUS conference, her voice quivering, she gave an evocative and deeply private speech approximately her past as an infant refugee, thumping the lectern as she vowed to fight government cuts to bursaries, colleges and the NHS.

However inside some hours of her victory, college students on the university of Cambridge called for a referendum on whether their union have to disaffiliate from the NUS. Two days later, students at Oxford, York, Durham, Edinburgh, King’s college London and the London college of Economics had referred to as for their personal unions to sever ties with NUS, plunging the union into crisis My general.

Jack may additionally, the leader of the Cambridge marketing campaign to disaffiliate, known as Bouattia’s election “a frightening message to Jewish college students in the uk”. In its editorial leader this week, the Jewish Chronicle stated: “The election of Bouattia as president of the NUS leaves no doubt as to in which that corporation now stands.”

#GenerationVote poster with Malia Bouattia.
facebook Twitter Pinterest
#GenerationVote poster with Malia Bouattia. Photograph: Vicky design/NUS internet site
Bouattia, who will no longer end up president officially till July, has pledged to meet the scholars who oppose her so vehemently and stated she turned into making plans to keep a low profile until her term starts. “One of the most crucial steps is to fulfill with all people, to speak approximately these worries, to heal the divisions,” she told the father or mother following her election.

A fierce leftwing campaigner whose family fled the Algerian civil war after terrorists planted a bomb at her father’s college, Bouattia earned her activist stripes in national social justice campaigns and in the Palestinian team spirit movement, speaking component in walkouts to protest in opposition to the struggle in Iraq even earlier than she left faculty in Birmingham.

But Bouattia has defined that by the point she commenced on the college of Birmingham, she felt remoted and disconnected from mainstream scholar existence, and struggled with mental health and academic pressures. It turned into there she released an envoy scheme for black students to address what she described as Eurocentric curriculums and lobbying for better woman illustration in academia.

Her first diploma become in way of life studies with French accompanied by way of an MPhil in put up-colonial principle; it turned into at some stage in this time that she became a scholar union rep, beginning her NUS profession.

Her passions and priorities, but, lie in international politics in preference to student troubles, which she recounted in her election speech at NUS conference. Bouattia has been a vocal ally of the Black Lives be counted motion, journeying the us to talk approximately racism on each facets of the Atlantic. At a debate remaining year, she changed into crucial of the disparity of attention within the media on sufferers of violence relying on pores and skin color, lamenting “the ongoing genocide of black lives across the world at the fingers of legitimised terrorists – the police”.

She is a common critic of the “colonisation” of curriculum at British universities and the white-focused recognition of literature and records, one of the key points of the influential Rhodes need to Fall marketing campaign at Cape metropolis and Oxford universities and some place else.

Assaults on the brand new NUS president show the restrict of loose expression for Muslims.
Michael Segalov, a member of the NUS NEC, describes her because the same person onstage as off, he stated, due to the fact she does now not transfer off. “She is devoted to it, 100% of the time. She doesn’t stop, it’s every day, all around the usa. I’ve never seen her ever turn down an invitation to talk, anywhere, the best if there’s a clash. And it’s not to sell herself, it’s to sell the motion, of anti-racism, anti-fascism which she has dedicated herself to for years.”

Malia Bouattia
Malia Bouattia

Bouattia has additionally been a regular speaker at rallies and debates on Israel, however her desire of language has once in a while regarded to echo a few deeply annoying tropes. In a 2011 article for her university Palestine society, she wrote: “The college of Birmingham is something of a Zionist outpost in British higher schooling. It also has the largest JSoc within the united states of america whose management is ruled by way of Zionist activists.”

Throughout the election campaign, extra than 50 heads of Jewish societies at universities across the usa wrote an open letter to Bouattia asking her to make clear her position on antisemitism. In an in depth respond, Bouattia denied she had ever had troubles with Jewish societies on campus. “I have a good time the potential of people and college students of all backgrounds to get collectively and explicit their backgrounds and faith brazenly and undoubtedly, and could preserve to accomplish that,” she wrote.

Her supporters praised her activist credentials. “She is the most hardworking, committed and principled person I’ve ever met in my time as a sabb [sabbatical officer],” stated Ali Milani, president of the university of Brunel scholar union.

However, it’s far her politics that most obviously appeals at a time whilst student funding is beneath stressed. Mahamid Ahmed, the postgraduate taught rep at the NUS NEC, stated he felt the union needed “a president who fights authorities policies and their attacks on college students nicely, and now not simply via rhetoric”.

Considered one of her maximum popular manifesto pledges, echoed with the aid of many candidates, is to campaign to repeal the Counter-Terror and safety Act, which makes referring college students to save you, the government’s anti-extremism programme, a statutory obligation.

The tales you need to study, in one on hand e mail
examine greater
The programme is unpopular amongst college students, and extra than 20 universities have held “students not Suspects” rallies. Bouattia gave evidence at a UN panel meeting in March, announcing the programme turned into “unfavorable each instructional freedom and pupil-lecturer family members through enforcing a climate of worry and suspicion, in particular among Muslim students and group of workers who are dis proportionally centered”.

However, the talk about her anti-Zionist views isn’t always going away. Simply days before the NUS convention in Brighton, the student newspaper the Tab published a previously deleted video of Bouattia giving a speech in 2014 in which she stated “with mainstream Zionist-led media outlets … resistance is supplied as an act of terrorism”.

Critics have talked about the phraseology echoes the antique antisemitic trope that Jews manage the media, though it is not an uncommon view heard in the Palestinian solidarity circles, wherein the mainstream media is claimed to take a pro-Israel slant.

“It’s an ideology that parts of the British press actively guide, and that’s what I criticised,” Bouattia advised the father or mother, however admitted she was looking to think extra carefully about how her phrases can be interpreted. “i am constantly learning, and attempt to constantly make certain that my language reflects my beliefs.”

Bouattia herself has often taken difficulty with deceptive language alternatives. In September 2014, two weeks after the murder of aid employee Alan Henning by way of Islamic kingdom, students had been requested to vote on a movement condemning the organization’s moves and expressing cohesion with the Kurdish forces combating towards it, “whilst expressing no confidence or trust within the US army intervention”.

Bouattia, as NUS black students’ officer, spoke passionately in opposition to the wording of the movement, which did not bypass, though she expressed solidarity with Kurdish efforts towards Isis and condemned the group’s “brutal actions”. “We recognise that condemnation of Isis appears to have become a justification for conflict and blatant Islamophobia,” she stated on the time. “This rhetoric exacerbates the difficulty handy and in essence is a further assault on those we goal to protect.”

Daniel Cooper, the scholar who proposed the original movement, said he couldn’t understand the objection, writing a weblog wherein he decried “a stranglehold of ‘identity politics’ on the student movement”.

A scholar guide to campaigning for refugees
examine more
every other near-equal movement become handed, however Bouattia located her feedback splashed throughout rightwing media, under headlines that alleged “the NUS had voted no longer to sentence Isis”.

In her conference speech, Bouattia denied she changed into the character depicted in media reviews. “I recognize lots of you will have seen my name dragged thru the mud with the aid of rightwing media, and can suppose I am a terrorist and my politics pushed through hate,” she said. “How incorrect this is. I know too properly the rate of terrorism, the effects of violence and oppression. I saw a rustic ripped apart by terror and became pressured into exile.”

Raised in Constantine, her family fled at some stage in the bloodshed of the Algerian civil battle whilst Bouattia became seven. “My dad turned into almost killed whilst a bomb became planted in his lecture theatre,” she said in her election speech. “One week in advance, I sat petrified beneath my number one faculty desk as terrorists rained gunfire on our teachers.”

It is a backstory she frequently relates in her speeches; she says she arrived within the uk not speakme a phrase of English. “It becomes tough, but it taught me not anything’s impossible.”

No matter the reams of poor publicity within the mainstream media, it’s far simple that Bouattia has nerves of metal and deep conviction to stand as president in the face of such virulent grievance and online abuse, frequently racist and sexualised, and that student activists love her for that willpower.

Bouattia herself has said the backlash against her vilification within the rightwing press boosted her marketing campaign, giving a nod in a speech to her “each day Mail groupies [who] mobilised many” to aid her.

NUS politics has more often than not contemplated the course of journey of the left in general, even though naturally left of the centre of gravity. Now there was a cultural shift within the British left, led by means of the popularity of veteran activist Jeremy Corbyn, Bouattia may come to symbolise but another symptom of the growing mistrust of leaders who play the political game, in favour of people who take their fight directly to the streets.